The Dangers of Punishment You Need to Know
We’ve all been there. Your dog’s barking incessantly, growling at the neighbor, lunging at other dogs, or worse, biting. It’s frustrating, it’s stressful, and you
JUST. WANT. IT. TO. STOP.
Immediately.
From your point of view, using punishment seems like the quickest way to get the job done, You shout “No!” or yank the leash, or grab their collar and, miraculously, the barking stops, the growling ceases, and suddenly, peace is restored. You can finally enjoy your coffee or walk without the embarrassing chaos of an ‘unhinged’ dog. However, this quick fix often comes with hidden costs.
Lets cover that fine print.
How punishment actually works
When you punish your dog, they learn that certain behaviors result in negative consequences. They might stop barking or growling in the moment, but they’re not understanding WHAT THEY SHOULD DO INSTEAD.
Remember behaviors happen for a reason. Especially big ones like the barking, lunging, growling, and snapping. Those reasons can span from excitement, to fear, to anxiety to stress. Your dog is displaying those big behaviors to communicate these feelings and to try to address them, either by getting closer to the trigger or to create distance from the trigger.
By punishing your dog for growling in the moment, you’re suppressing their behavior, but failing to address the underlying emotion.
Is it worth it? The Cost-Benefit Analysis your dog does
Essentially, you’ve told the dog, “I know you’re scared of that other dog, but you can’t growl at him to create distance”. Dogs are smart. The next time he feels the urge to growl at another dog at MacRitchie Reservoir, he’s going to do a quick cost-benefit analysis. “Is the reward of doing this behavior worth the risk of getting punished again?”.
If growling means he get the space he needs from the scary thing, he might continue it, acknowledging that growling is worth the risk of your punishment. But if the punishment from you is severe enough, he might decide to keep quiet and suffer through his fear until it gets too much to bear and he lashes out in another way. Or alternately, he might learn that since growling doesn’t get him the distance he wants, he needs to escalate his behavior to barking and lunging on the leash without the warning growl which is sure to catch you by surprise!
Punishment creates confusion and more aggression
Do you see what happens here? Instead of teaching the dog a more acceptable way of dealing with his emotion or fears, we’ve created confusion and left him to come to his own conclusions on what to do instead (more often than not, those conclusions lead to more frustration for humans).
Moreover, dogs are quick studies, if you keep punishing your dog or delivering negative consequences for behaviors, they soon start to associate YOU with those negative feelings which not only damages your relationship, but can in the long run potentially result in your dog lashing out on you! In fact the majority of dog aggression cases I work on are cases of guardian directed aggression, where the dog has bitten household members!
Essentially punishment, or telling them to stop a behavior, is the vaguest instruction you can provide to your dog.
Its as if your boss gives you a project to work on and
when you share it when them, they tell you its shit and send you back to redo it. They haven’t told you what was wrong with it or how to fix it, just that it was crap and you need to try again. How frustrating is that? You revise it and get the same feedback again. You keep going back and forth until maybe you get lucky and get it right. But the whole process took forever, created frustration for both you and your boss and basically left you both with a bad memory of the whole experience.
The vicious cycle of punishment
On the human end, while punishing or ‘correcting’ your dog in the moment might seem like it works, you’ll soon find that you are delivering more and more punishments/corrections. That’s because you find that punishments are effective in getting the result you want in the moment. But remember these punishments are only creating more frustration between your and your dog in the long run
Alternately, if you find that your punishment or correction hasn’t worked in the moment, you might be tempted to escalate it into something harsher which might work in the moment, but will ultimately make you feel like crap because let’s face it – you didn’t get a dog to police their behavior 24/7 – you got them to share your love and life and create joyful memories with.
If you want lasting change, Punishment won’t cut it
Using punishment to stop behaviors is like putting a band-aid on a wound without cleaning it first. It might cover up the problem temporarily, but it doesn’t address the underlying issue. Your dog’s still feeling the same emotions, and those feelings will find another outlet. The risk of escalation without warning becomes a real concern.
Furthermore, punishment can exacerbate issues like anxiety, fear, and aggression. Your dog might start to see you as a source of stress rather than a source of comfort and safety. Imagine how confusing and scary it must be for a dog to be punished from the one person who they look to for guidance in navigating this weird human world.
What’s more effective than punishment?
Instead of punishment, focus on understanding the root cause of the behavior and addressing it through positive reinforcement and training. This approach builds a relationship based on trust and respect, not fear and punishment. For instance, if your dog growls because they’re scared of another dog, helping them learn better ways of coping with that fear will be more effective than trying to silence them through fear.
Most importantly, when you’re working with a trainer and they recommend a punishment or correction, question them on what it actually accomplishes. And think about it from the dog’s perspective. Are you being clear in your communication to the dog on WHAT THEY SHOULD DO or are you giving them a vague no with no guidance?
As our dog’s guardians, its our responsibility to show them acceptable behaviors in various situations. A good, skilled trainer will always create the positive conditions to get the behavior we want out of the dog and teach you to do the same. A less skilled one will simply help you suppress the behavior.
Remember, our goal is not just to stop unwanted behaviors but to understand our dogs and help them feel safe and loved and confident in how to navigate our world in an acceptable fashion. This is the foundation of a strong, lasting bond with your canine companion.
If you want to learn more about the long-term effects of using punishments you can click on the resources linked below or visit the websites of the leading associations such as the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB) and the Singapore Veterinary Association on their positions on the matter.
Sources:
RSPCA Use of Correction Collars
AVSAB Positioning Statement on Punishment
Peta on Use of Correction Collars
Impact of Aversives on Dogs – Nature.com